I can’t remember very much about Derren Brown’s guide to practicing stoicism in an unhappy world, Happy. This is the follow up. Pretty good fun, more like a chapbook and diary (his father died during Covid). I’ll no doubt forget all the lessons learned here too.
Stoics taught us fortitude comes from controlling our thoughts and actions. The common mistake we make is to try and manage things we cannot (serenity prayer). Derren suggests, You are not fragile, you have all the resources you need.
Without stoic wisdom, what is our default mode? Mine is to read books and leave the real world behind, or in front, or wherever it goes when you’re reading.
No feeling is final. Rainer Maria Rilke, The Book of Hours.
Let everything happen to you.
Beauty and terror
Just keep going
Leonard Cohen Beautiful Losers:
How can I begin anything new with all of yesterday in me?
I remember moments of my own excessive certainty; my many years as a Christian patiently explaining to anyone who would listen how Jesus must have risen from the dead. There were simply no other explanations for the events that took place. P31
Whenever a spiritual revelation is enshrined in an institution invented to carry its meaning through time it is easy to understand how its guardians can become overprotective of the treasure they are responsible for, especially if their access to the original it theoretical rather than experiential…there is a clear tendency in subsequent generations to overdefine and concretize the original revelation.
Divinise the one to whom the original revelation came.
Cf. political revelations, ‘Marixsm-Leninism’. Maoism, Fascism.
The New Seekers in the early seventies would like to teach the world to sing in perfect harmony. The Seekers, a small Chicago based group that believed the world would end 21st December 1954 at 7am. A flood would wipe out humanity. But they would be saved. Picked up by UFOs with whom they were in contact by psychic links with the planet Clarion via automatic writing. The group had been infiltrated by social psychologists that monitored what happened next, when the flood didn’t happen and the alien never showed up. The group, like the Jehovah’s before them had given away all of their belongings and removed all metal items from their clothing such as fly zips and bra straps, in accordance with the instructions they had received.
Tears and disbelief were put aside when a message came through the channel of automatic writing that the group had been spared the coming apocalypse. And because of their belief God had also spared the world.
The believers doubled-down on their belief with an outpouring of evangelism. Much like anti-vaxxers, Trumpism and a belief in QAnon hadn’t been channelled, not be automatic writing, but by Russian state hackers.
Michael W. Miller, writing in the Observer about Janet Malcolm makes sense of this cognitive dissonance by quoting her.
Hypocrisy is the grease that keeps society functioning in an agreeable way, by allowing for human fallibility and reconciling the seemingly irreconcilable need for order and pleasure.
Aristotle: the good life as principally steering a course between the extremes of temperament. Neither intellectual cowardice, nor plastic New Age wisdom.
We have largely forgotten the role of Fortune in our lives. The Greeks were very keen to remind us. Pride, in our modern mantras, at the mercy of FATE.
Schopenhauer mankind trapped between pain and boredom.
Slippery selves every face having its opposite.
Rilke: People in love are the furthest distance.
Arthur C Clarke (1962) Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic [or Star Trek]
We live longer and more happily when we have friends around us.
David Bosiano (2018) Emotional Success.
Prosocial feelings, no man is an island.
Pride in ourself(ves) and others.
John Paul Satre: ‘bad faith’ , an insincere existence.
Nietschean ideal of ‘Become who you are’.
Jonathan Rauch (2018) The Happiness Curve.
Wait, Wait. Wait. Life gets better after your forties.
Paul Harris, American magician: A baby arrives in the world and embarks upon a gradual process of disenchantment.
Busyness. A marker of success. Doing becomes being.
Identity: cognitive dissonance, rationalize and edit out what does not fit in with notions of ourself.
Jim Steinsmeyer, designer of magic and theatrical special effects. Magicians guard an empty safe. [cf Wizard of Oz, when the curtain pulled a man pedalling a bike and shouting through a megaphone]
Emanuel Levinas: Face to face encounters the bedrock of our existence.
Beauty, striking beauty, causes the body to ache.
Shyness, can make those suffering from the condition (introverts) seem cold and aloof. Susan Cain (2012) Quiet.
Shyness a fear of negative judgement.
277 Schopenhauer. Most people discover ‘when they look back on their life that they have been living the whole time ad interim, and they are surprised to see that which they let go by so unregarded and unenjoyed was precisely their life, was precisely that in expectation of which they lived.’