Sean Connolly (2022) On Every Tide: The Making and Remaking of the Irish World.

My mother’s maiden name was Connolly. As a child, she was sent ‘home’ to Ireland, during the Second World War, with her sister (my Auntie Phyllis) to safeguard them from German bombs and to make their Roman Catholic faith bombproof. She didn’t talk about it, certainly not to me, but there were whispers of predatory paedophilic attempts. And as outcast Irish, they were treated like cow shit. My Auntie Phyllis and my mum had a lifelong-bond based on shared hardship. They were Irish immigrants of a different kind, but they faced the same kind of prejudices and poverty.

My dad was born in Northern Ireland. But he came here as a child. His dad was here and his mum died early. He went to Our Holy Redeemer’s School (still going strong) in Whitecrook. He had a Scottish accent. Not Irish, like my Uncle Charlie and my godmother, Auntie Josie. Or like Pat McDaid’s dad, or Sporter Sweeney or Boxer Toi’s dad. We’re second or third generation and experience the cultural fade of fitting in and marrying into the existing population. Most of us remain mad Glasgow Celtic fans.

In the United States, it is evident that there is little or no difference between the second and third generation Irish who voted Republican and for Trump, the moron’s moron. A generation ago, when John Kennedy won by a very slim majority (and a bit of electoral cheating) Catholics were demonised and if it wasn’t for the electoral blocks delivered wholesale by Capos of the Irish-Catholic, Democratic, immigrant machine, he would have lost.

The Ireland my Uncle Charlie and Auntie Josie left a lifetime ago was rural. What little industry there was in the North, in Belfast, weaving and shipbuilding. The population halved after the Irish Famine (there was also a Scottish Famine mostly in the Highland and Islands) but it was in Ireland were subsistence farming meant the humble potato was breakfast, lunch and dinner for millions that famine took around a million lives directly and indirectly.

Ironically, the root cause may have been a cargo of seed potatoes from across the Atlantic in 1845. The population of Ireland had doubled from 4.4million in 1791 to above 8 million in 1841. Almost 90% of the population depended on the potato. The more prosperous tenant farmer who could afford a cow had assets to sell. Most did not. All they could offer was cheap labour.

An estimated 109 000 sailed for North America in 1846, almost double the total of the beginning of the Famine. What we now know as Canada, Australia, New Zealand and Argentina were less popular destinations. For those with little or no money, the short hop across the Irish Sea meant that tens of thousands a week ended up in the ports of Liverpool and Glasgow.

In their poverty and need, we were caricatured as sub-human and disease stricken. There was some truth in the latter. Ships bringing export goods from America and the British colonies filled their holds with human ballast, which they could charge a fee, and make the return journeys profitable.

For babies, one-in-seven did not survive the journey. Those packed below deck had a nominal space of 6 feet by 3 feet for married couples. Toilets were rudimentary. Women, in particular, crouched down and shat and urinated wherever they could. Water and food were rationed. Typhoid and dysentery were not. Coffin ships delivered their cargoes to cities that started asking for bonds to offset the cost of treating the ill, but which pushed up prices and more ships towards Canadian ports. But more than 90% made it ashore and became citizens. Women, in particular, became a prized asset.

When my Uncle Charlie left Ireland the population was still haemorrhaging the young and fit, but the destination pre-and-post War—with the Hungry Thirties as an interlude—was to British cities. Cities that were crying out for cheap labour the Irish specialised in. Labour that dug canals with pick and shovels, connected railways across continents, created reservoirs and build road after road and house by house helped make Britain and its former colonies Irish enough to have St Patrick’s Day parades and indulge the bonhomie of a green and pleasant land usurped by British rule. Step forward President Joe Biden, following in the footsteps of JFK, Jimmy Carter, and even Ronnie Reagan whose aspirations were more Protestant blue blood.

Ireland, that Irish tiger that has become a parking space for big corporations—with promises of low taxation—inside the EEC has seen its population double from when my Uncle Charlie left Ireland to around five million. It has more Polish immigrants than Britain. And to my great shame has also played the race card. Demonising immigrants while most of its wealth, like in Britain, goes to the rich and Irish 1%. The most oppressed people ever banner, once worn with pride, is now a rallying cry to deport and demonise those at the bottom. Cultural fade. Not for me. I’m not buying into that propaganda. We’ve a different kind of famine in housing and public services and it’s the rich that we need to pay their way. Not the poor, oppressed masses that America once claimed to represent as a sanctuary and offer a welcome. I’m not ashamed to be part Irish. I’m ashamed of such policies finding fertile soil in whatever side of the Atlantic you happened to be standing on. Sean Connolly offers a comprehensive account of what it means to be Irish, but that doesn’t mean the story is ended. It’s still being written by us now and I don’t like what I’m seeing or hearing.

https://amzn.to/48khBJ5

  • 😈 “Unleash the Beastie! https://bit.ly/bannkie
  •  📚 Share the Magic, Share the Page! 🌟 #BeastieNovel #BookBuzz” 😈

https://bit.ly/bannkie

.

Scotland 0—1 Northern Ireland.

Northern Ireland’s first win at Hampden for fifty years, with a Connor Bradley goal after 32 minutes. Scotland loses seven-a-row for the first time since…the last time…Scotland fans boo Rule Britannia and the British National Anthem. Pick your own headline. Who really gives a shit?

I know there are Scotland diehards. I’m not one of their crew. (I’m a Celtic diehard; booing Rule Britannia is second nature). And this game panned out much like a Celtic game in which we lost to a diddy team and were expected to win. We know that the home team are going to get much of the ball. The home team, in this case being Scotland.

We know that the away team, in this case Northern Ireland will play with eleven men behind the ball, with a nominal striker not striking much.

We’ll here the usual clichés about we need to move the ball quicker. We need to have runners. Our wingers need to find space. The problem here is we don’t have wingers, although we do have guys that push wide.

Our defenders need to defend. There is a good reason Nathan Patterson doesn’t get a game for Everton. He sold a goal here and was lucky not to sell another when he was robbed on the half-way line. Shea Charles didn’t have to do very much inside the box, but move his feet to hold off Cooper and pick his spot. He put it past the post. Scotland rode their luck. Andy Robertson goes off injured again.

We’ll hear all the usual bilge about Northern Ireland defending stoutly. All the cliché that have already been spoken will be repeated in a more sonorous voice as if they are new. Let me put this into context. Northern Ireland brought on a Queens Park player after 80 odds minutes. In other words, they bring on a footballer who is an amateur.  

Scotland bring on guys that have done it before at this level, only they haven’t. Lewis Ferguson, captain on Bologna, for example, made a real difference. He didn’t. He throws himself about and lacks guile. I wouldn’t want him at Celtic. He does have a few chance which he fluffs.

Lawrence Shankland comes on and has two chances. He got his shot away, in a crowed box, and it was blocked by Spencer.  

Ferguson has a header tipped over by Farrell-Peacock. You’d expect him to make such a save.

Farrell-Peacock comes out and makes an untimely mess of things. It was on par with Nathan Patterson’s embarrassing moment in the first-half. But the Northern Irish teenagers still had a bit to do and got luck with a nick from a defender. Farrell-Peacock comes out for a cross and flaps. He’s nowhere near the ball. The Hearts’ striker and top scorer in Scottish football only needs to nod it in. He misses.

These things happen. It’s been happening a lot lately. I’m not sure about Gunn in goal. At best bang average. I just hope Celtic don’t try to sign him as another deadweight, as we’ve been extremely guilt of late. Jack Butland, of course, would be ideal, but he’s English and Rangers players now rarely make the Scotland squad. Nathan Patterson is terrible. Ralston, his backup, worse. We don’t have any decent central defenders. Left back, we’re pretty well covered. Midfield, decent enough. Nothing up top.

Can we beat Germany at home in the opening game of the Euros? Nah. But all the pressure is off and we’ve nothing to lose. A bit like Northern Ireland tonight. This game will be forgotten before the ink on the latest scandal emerges.  

https://amzn.to/48khBJ5

  • 😈 “Unleash the Beastie! https://bit.ly/bannkie
  •  📚 Share the Magic, Share the Page! 🌟 #BeastieNovel #BookBuzz” 😈

Sebastian Barry (2009) The Secret Scripture.

You should never step into the book you’ve read before (or something like that). Sebastian Barry is a terrific writer. This book won the Costa Book of the Year 2008. The Secret Scripture is in many ways the story of Ireland after the Famine, with a centurion Roseanne McNulty providing the handwritten shape of her life played out against the Civil War years in Ireland and the world wars that also came to Sligo.

Beginnings: Roseanne’s Testimony of Herself (Patient, Roscommon Regional Mental Hospital 1957—)

Roseanne’s testimony of herself is a narrative story of her girlhood and young adult life before she was incarcerated in Sligo’s Lunatic Asylum. The question of why she is there is implicit in her writing. But there is another narrative interbody with it. This comes from the psychiatrist who oversees her care, Dr Grene. The old hospital is closing. He is nearing retirement. In trying to decide about where Rosanne should go, the rights and wrongs of what has been done to her, he also has to map out the shape of his faltering marriage and what to do with his own life. One lies on and relies on the other. Judgement is dependent on knowing what you know and what you don’t know.

‘…it wasn’t so much whether she’d written the truth about herself or told the truth, or believed what she wrote or said was true, or even whether they were true things in themselves. The important thing seemed to me that the person who wrote and spoke was admirable, living and complete…from a psychiatric point of view I had totally failed to ‘help’ her to, to prise open the locked lids of the past…I preferred Roseann’s untruth to Fr Gaunt’s truth, because the former radiated health.’

Father Gaunt haunts Roseanne’s life as priests haunted Ireland. Roseanne was immediately suspect for being female. For priests such as Father Gaunt, even the Virgin Mary would have been suspect unless the Lord Jesus vouched for her. Roseanne was also suspect because she was extraordinarily beautiful. The kind of beauty that led men to temptation. Father Gaunt’s solution to marry a sixteen-year-old girl to a widower three times her age, had the merit of taking her out of circulation. And since she was Protestant destined for Hell, making her a follower not only of her husband, but the one true church and saving her soul.

Roseanne proved to be not as pliable material as Father Gaunt hoped. Her extraordinary story is not of failure, but of high spirits. A different kind of beauty. I can never remember what I wrote the last time, so I’ll reiterate it here, the ending was too chocolate-book for my liking. But this is a great story. Well worth the reading or re-reading. Read on.

https://amzn.to/48khBJ5

  •    😈 “Unleash the Beastie! https://bit.ly/bannkie
  •  📚 Share the Magic, Share the Page! 🌟 #BeastieNovel #BookBuzz” 😈

Paul Lynch (2023) Prophet Song

Paul Lynch (2023) Prophet Song.

Writers are told, never start with the weather. Paul Lynch starts with the weather in his debut novel, Red Sky in the Morning. Prophet Song, Lynch’s latest award-winning novel, starts with the night weather and a knocking on the door.

‘The night has come and she has not heard the knocking, standing at the window, looking out at the garden. How the dark gathers without sound the cherry trees. It gathers the last of the leaves and the leaves do not resist the dark but accept the dark in whispers.’

Long convoluted sentences that don’t make sense yet they do. A writer’s job is make things worse for his or her characters.

Mother Courage, Ellish Stack has a Phd and a good job. Her dad, Simon, was a scientist too, but her mother is dead, and he’s paranoid, and in the early stages of dementia. Larry, her husband works for the teacher’s union. They’re respectfully upper-middle class and their eldest son is in line to become that icon of respectability—he has a university place to study medicine. His future is set. She has three other children, including baby, Ben. 

The knocking on the window is their Kristallnacht. They are not Jews. But Larry Stack as a trade-unionist is an enemy of the people. Two officers from the Irish Government’s newly formed GNSB have come to question him. Have come to warn his family. This will be your fate if you oppose us. In the name of freedom, they’re asking them to give up their freedom of thought and assembly, freedom of the press and mass media. It’s a Trumpian scenario we’re all familiar with.

‘The world is always ending over and over again in one place but not another, and the end of the world is always a local event. It comes to your country, visits your town, knocks on the door of your house, and becomes to others but some distant warning, a brief report on the news, an echo of events that has passed into folklore.’

Prophecy comes from the prayer-book of it couldn’t happen to us. Inevitably it does. Germany, Chile, Spain and Ireland itself had their ‘Disappeared’. Ellish refuses to believe that Larry is gone. Disappeared.

The Irish Government dictatorship will somehow see sense. Suspend the Emergency Powers and the curfews and the rounding up of enemies of the people. Her son, Mark, the doctor-to-be will not be drafted into the militia and fascist army of the governing forces. The logic of inevitably and disbelief creates a toxic fatalism.

‘We were offered visas to Australia, but we turned them down. How could we have known what was going to happen? Leaving everything behind was impossible.’

The impossible is always impossible until it becomes possible. Prophet Song seems prescient. ‘Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.’ An epigram attributed to the philosopher and essayist George Santayana. It is often paraphrased as ‘Those who do not learn history are doomed to repeat it.’

Santayana first used this expression in his work ‘The Life of Reason: The Phases of Human Progress,’ which was published in 1905. Mother Courage, the heroine in the novel 2023 by Ellish Stack, illustrates that not much progress has been made. We wait to bear witness to see if the moron’s moron Trump will be re-elected President. Prophet Song may well follow this playbook in American society. Hyperbole? I hope so.

  • 😈 “Unleash the Beastie! https://bit.ly/bannkie
  •  📚 Share the Magic, Share the Page! 🌟 #BeastieNovel #BookBuzz” 😈

David Gange (2019) The Frayed Atlantic Edge: A Historian’s Journey from Shetland to the Channel.

Historian David Gange journey by kayak around the coast of Scotland facing the Atlantic in winter sounds like madness. Takes in Ireland in spring time. He crosses the channel to the less ragged coast of Bardsey in Wales and Bristol and Cornwall in the summer.  He offers a low-down view from the sea that mimics E.P. Thompson’s bottom-up view of class history.  

Gange rejects a London-centric view of the world. An imperialistic vision that for example classified Scottish islands as empty land until the English arrived.  Scotland was close to home, but full of Scotsmen, women and children that insisted on speaking in their own strange tongue and had strange customs and culture. Scots Gaelic was the mark of a marked man. Similar to Irish Gaelic, or even Welsh, the language of Atlantic trading routes that predated Britain and British as a unifying narrative.

Hanoverian kings in London outlawed kilt and tartan. Daniel Defoe, a spy for the English billeted in Edinburgh before the union of Scotland and England in 1707, wrote to his paymasters and claimed that for every Scot in favour of Union, ninety-nine were against. Riots were quelled. King George, after 1745 Culloden, punished all Highlanders even his would-be supporters. ‘Butcher’ Cumberland imposed a reign of terror.

‘the English forced a union on Scotland that was as violent and unwelcome as that of 1801 would be for Ireland.’

Oliver Cromwell spoke in terms many English kings understood, ‘hell or Connact’, coastal Galway, Connemara. In Munster, in a splintery rockbound stronghold of Gaelic, 300 mainly women and children were killed by Cromwell’s troops.  A holy man, Dairaid O’Sullivan, run through on Scarif Island. Cromwell forced half the population (his troops hadn’t murdered) west, towards the coast and regions thought to be sparsely populated such as Connemara.

The brutal Sutherland clearances. Its population reduced and redistributed. Pushed from valuable pasture land towards the coast.  

‘The modern population of Sutherland is half what it was in the early nineteen century.’

Many of those that clung onto their holding or crofts were undone by the famine of the late 1840s.

‘Potatoes were the miracle food of the early modern coast. Visitors to the Scottish and Irish islands in the eighteenth century describe a population living in abject poverty, but who were tall and strong. These tubers carried far more nutrients and were more efficient, damp resistant and voluminous than the grain on which the islanders had previously relied.’

 Gange rallies against the unifying influence of Enlightenment and the notion of progress leaving those outside it in the dark. But he’s not anti-science. Just its overarching hegemonic influence that doesn’t allow other, coastal, dwellers to tell their stories. ‘The Highland Problem,’ was not an invention of Highlanders, but of the big cities, London, Edinburgh and even Dublin that managed their decline from afar and claimed the high ground. Enlightenment is not singular, but plural and many of the questions and answers for how we should live comes from the watery shores and poetic view of the world Gange champions, based on observation and direct experience.

In saving the world, you need to save the story of that world.  The British Education Acts 1870 and 1872 which aimed to unify the nation around a common curriculum and the currency of the English language excluded the Gaelic languages of the coastal people.

Gange describes their effect ‘as an unmitigated disaster for many coastal zones’ with many young people leaving and not returning. Others returning but unable to speak their native language. But here there is a happy ending of sorts in economic recession (which should be useful during the current rolling recession) which saw an island renaissance and return to the innate languages of the peoples and the myriad and enriching connections that entails.

Famine, clearances and Educational Acts are part of the narrative of who owns the land owns the narrative of what is said about the land. The languages of the people on the periphery are growing slowly back to life. Gage identifies a contemporary problem of multinational companies like Shell who buy up Britishness and Irishness and pollute the water and land for profit. They kill people in Nigeria for oil.

Ireland can be bought wholesale. (I’m thinking here of the Irish government knocking back the 14 billion euros that Apple should have paid in back taxes to the state).  And while the Irish state makes a net profit from the EEC (it receives more than it contributes) selling off Atlantic resources leaves a nation indebted.

‘Corporations registered in Norway, Russia, Canada, the Netherland and Spain draw greater profits from the waters west of Ireland than do Irish interests.’

Small and local might be better. But the paradox that Gange doesn’t address is such interests are easily brushed aside by big business, multinationals. Sometimes we need more, not less government. The explosion of poetry in the 1930s during the Great Depression didn’t change the world. W.H.Auden, Stephen Spender, Louise Mac Niece anti-war poetry didn’t prevent the Second World War. Community versus Commerce (whisper it, it used to be called Communism versus Capitalism) and we all know how that went. I’m on David Ganges side. He’s optimistic. I’m pessimistic, but I hope his vision is the one that endures. More power to the community. Less power to the rich that own the people on the coast land—and mainland—and stir our fears for their own financial gains.